Vivaldi, Opera and the Phoenix: A Walk Through Musical Venice

From a museum of old violins to the Red Priest's baptismal font: the opera house that burned twice, Rossini's first triumphs, singing gondoliers and the foundling girls who played for Vivaldi at the Pietà

Venice · 11 stops · 27 min audio · Generated

  1. 1. Museo della Musica (San Maurizio)

    Campo San Maurizio, San Marco, 30124 Venezia VE, Italy

    Push open the door of a church that no longer holds Mass, and instead of saints in the side chapels you find violins, violas, cellos and mandolins resting in glass cases like relics. This is San Maurizio, rebuilt in a cool neoclassical style from 1806, and today it is the Museo della Musica, a small museum of old instruments. It is the perfect overture for a walk through what was once the most musical city in Europe.

    Why Venice? Because for three centuries this city was a factory of sound. In 1501 a printer from the Marche called Ottaviano Petrucci published here the first book of polyphonic music printed with movable type, a collection of songs known as the Odhecaton. Suddenly music could travel. Venetian presses went on to print madrigals, masses and sonatas for the whole continent, and composers from Flanders to Bohemia wanted to be published here.

    And then there were the makers. In workshops a few streets from here, luthiers such as Matteo Goffriller and Domenico Montagnana built cellos so generous in sound that soloists today still compete to play them. Venetian instruments tend to be broad, warm and a little flamboyant... rather like the city itself. Look closely at the varnish on the oldest pieces, that deep reddish glow, and you are looking at a recipe nobody has fully reconstructed.

    There is a quiet link with the stops ahead. The new church was designed by Giannantonio Selva together with Antonio Diedo, and Selva is the same architect who, a few years earlier, had built the opera house of La Fenice. So the room you are standing in was drawn by the hand that gave Venice its most famous stage.

    Music in Venice was never only for palaces. It belonged to gondoliers, orphans, priests, gamblers and doges. Over the next couple of hours you will meet a red-haired priest who wrote some five hundred concertos, an opera house that burned down twice, and girls whose names survive only as Anna Maria of the violin. Step out into Campo Santo Stefano and cross it to the small white church at its southern end, close to the Accademia bridge.

  2. 2. San Vidal

    Campo Santo Stefano, San Marco, 30124 Venezia VE, Italy

    In front of you rises a white church front with tall columns and a triangular pediment, tucked into the southern corner of Campo Santo Stefano just before the Accademia bridge. San Vidal no longer serves a parish. Its nave has become a concert hall, and the posters by the door promise Vivaldi, Vivaldi and a little more Vivaldi.

    That is less of a gimmick than it sounds. A church has stood here since the Middle Ages, and the façade you see, in the manner of Palladio, was added in the early 1700s, while Vivaldi himself was alive and working on the other side of San Marco. Inside, above the high altar, hangs a painting by Vittore Carpaccio from 1514: Saint Vitalis on a white horse, armour gleaming, while saints look down from a balcony like spectators at a concert.

    Sit through a concert here and you discover something Venetian builders understood very well. Stone, wood and water make a resonant box. Baroque string music was written for rooms like this, not for vast modern halls. A single violin fills the nave without any amplification, the notes bouncing off marble and coming back to you a fraction of a second later, softened and warm. Composers wrote with that echo in mind.

    There is a paradox, though. Vivaldi was hugely famous in his lifetime, then almost completely forgotten for nearly two centuries after his death in 1741. Much of his music came back only in the twentieth century, when bundles of his manuscripts surfaced in private collections in the 1920s and ended up in the National Library in Turin. The Four Seasons, which you now hear in every hotel lobby, was a rediscovery, not an unbroken tradition.

    So when the players tune up here in the evening, they are playing music that was very nearly lost, in a church that has outlived the parish it was built for. Walk back north along the western side of the campo, past the long wall of Palazzo Pisani, towards the tall church with the leaning tower.

  3. 3. Campo Santo Stefano & Palazzo Pisani (Conservatorio Benedetto Marcello)

    Campo Santo Stefano, San Marco, 30124 Venezia VE, Italy

    Stand in the middle of Campo Santo Stefano, one of the largest squares in Venice, and listen before you look. If a window is open in the great palace on the western side, you may catch scales on a piano, a trumpet repeating the same phrase, a soprano warming up. That palace is Palazzo Pisani, and for well over a century it has housed the city's school of music, today the Conservatorio Benedetto Marcello.

    Benedetto Marcello, whose name it carries, was a Venetian nobleman, lawyer and composer born in 1686. He is remembered for a wicked little pamphlet of 1720, Il teatro alla moda, a satire on the opera business. It advises composers never to read the libretto and singers to chat on stage while their colleagues are singing. Many readers have seen in it a dig at a certain red-haired composer and impresario... Antonio Vivaldi.

    The palace itself is enormous. The Pisani family began it in the early 1600s and kept enlarging it for more than a century, until it reached back towards the Grand Canal around two internal courtyards. Students now practise where patricians once held their balls. One of them was a young Venetian called Luigi Nono, who studied here with the composer Gian Francesco Malipiero and went on to become one of the boldest voices of twentieth-century music.

    Now turn to the church at the northern end. Santo Stefano belonged to Augustinian friars, and it is the resting place of Giovanni Gabrieli, who died in 1612. As organist of San Marco he wrote for several choirs and brass groups placed in different galleries, so that sound reached the listener from every side. His Sonata pian' e forte of 1597 is often cited as one of the first pieces to mark loud and soft in the score. A year after his death, Claudio Monteverdi arrived to run the music of San Marco, and stayed for thirty years.

    One more oddity: part of the church is built over a canal, which flows right underneath it. And its bell tower leans so alarmingly that you are better off judging it from the next square. Leave the campo at its northern corner, past the church door, and walk into Campo Sant'Anzolo.

  4. 4. Campo Sant'Anzolo (Teatro Sant'Angelo & Palazzo Duodo)

    Campo Sant'Anzolo, San Marco, 30124 Venezia VE, Italy

    Turn round in Campo Sant'Anzolo and look back over the rooftops: there is the bell tower of Santo Stefano, tilting against the sky like a tired guest at the end of a long party. Engineers have shored it up more than once. But this calm square, lined with palaces and a little oratory, has musical ghosts of its own.

    Until the 1830s a church of Sant'Angelo stood here, and close by, towards the Grand Canal, stood the Teatro Sant'Angelo, which opened in 1677. It was a modest commercial opera house, and it became Antonio Vivaldi's laboratory. From the 1710s onwards he worked here not only as a composer but as an impresario: hiring singers, haggling over fees, painting the posters in his head, and staging his own operas, among them Orlando furioso in 1727.

    Think about that for a moment. A Catholic priest, ordained in 1703, running an opera company in the most competitive theatre market in Europe. He said a chest complaint kept him from saying Mass, yet he travelled constantly, rehearsed late into the night and toured with the singer Anna Girò, which set tongues wagging. In 1737 the cardinal archbishop of Ferrara went as far as forbidding him to enter the city to stage an opera.

    Now find Palazzo Duodo on the square. In January 1801 the Neapolitan composer Domenico Cimarosa died here, the man whose comic opera Il matrimonio segreto had so delighted Vienna that, the story goes, the emperor had the whole thing performed again the same night. Cimarosa had been imprisoned in Naples for his republican sympathies, and rumour soon claimed he had been poisoned. The doctors who examined him found illness, not poison, but Venice preferred the darker version.

    Two lives a century apart, both tangled up with the stage. Venetian opera was never a polite art. It was a business, a scandal and an addiction. Head north out of the square and follow the lanes for a couple of minutes to Campo San Beneto, where a cinema keeps the name of Rossini alive.

  5. 5. Campo San Beneto & Teatro Rossini (former Teatro San Benedetto)

    Calle del Teatro, San Marco, 30124 Venezia VE, Italy

    Ahead of you is a cinema, and that is the surprising part. The entrance near Campo San Beneto carries the name Rossini, and it stands on the site of the Teatro San Benedetto, one of the grandest opera houses of eighteenth-century Venice. It opened in 1755, burned in 1773 and was rebuilt at once, because in this city an opera house was not a luxury... it was infrastructure.

    On 22 May 1813, a twenty-one-year-old from Pesaro called Gioachino Rossini premiered L'italiana in Algeri here, an opera he had written in a matter of weeks. The story of an Italian girl who outwits a Turkish bey was a triumph. Earlier that year his serious opera Tancredi had opened at La Fenice. In a single season Venice had crowned him, and the theatre was later renamed in his honour.

    There is a twist that links this spot to the next one. In the 1780s the society of noble box holders who ran San Benedetto lost the building after a legal battle with the Venier family, who owned the ground. Furious, the members decided to build a new and bigger theatre of their own a few streets away. They called it La Fenice, the phoenix: a company rising from the ashes of its own defeat.

    Now look across Campo San Beneto at the huge Gothic palace with rows of pointed windows. It is Palazzo Pesaro degli Orfei, later the home and workshop of the designer Mariano Fortuny. The odd second half of its name comes from a music society, the Orfei, which met inside from the late eighteenth century, holding concerts and balls. In this neighbourhood even the palaces are named after music.

    Rossini, by the way, did not stay. Within a few years he was writing for Naples, Paris and the world, and he stopped composing operas altogether at thirty-seven, after William Tell. But it was Venice that heard him first as a grown-up composer. Follow the lanes south-east for a few minutes to Campo San Fantin, where the phoenix still stands.

  6. 6. Teatro La Fenice & Campo San Fantin

    Campo San Fantin 1965, San Marco, 30124 Venezia VE, Italy

    The pale neoclassical front in Campo San Fantin, with its columns and a golden phoenix over the door, looks almost modest. It is a disguise. Behind it is the most famous opera house in Venice, Teatro La Fenice, and nearly everything you would see inside has been rebuilt at least once.

    La Fenice opened in May 1792, designed by Giannantonio Selva for the nobles who had lost San Benedetto. It quickly became the stage where Italian opera made history: Rossini's Tancredi in 1813, Bellini's I Capuleti e i Montecchi in 1830, and then Verdi, with Ernani, Rigoletto in 1851 and, on 6 March 1853, La Traviata. The first night was a fiasco. Verdi wrote to a friend that he did not know whether the fault was his or the singers', and that time would judge.

    The theatre's name turned out to be prophetic. In December 1836 a fire gutted it, and it was rebuilt within a year. Then, on the night of 29 January 1996, it burned again, so fiercely that the glow lit up the whole city and helicopters scooped water from the canals. It was arson. Two electricians, working for a firm facing penalties for delays on renovation work, had set the fire, and both were later convicted.

    The rebuilding became a detective story. How do you recreate gilded boxes and painted ceilings that have turned to ash? Part of the answer came from cinema: Luchino Visconti's 1954 film Senso opens with a performance inside La Fenice, and its colour footage helped the restorers. The theatre reopened in December 2003, just as Venetians had demanded, com'era, dov'era... as it was, where it was. Stravinsky's The Rake's Progress had premiered on this stage in 1951; the music came back too.

    Beside the theatre, the sober stone building is the Ateneo Veneto, once the Scuola di San Fantin, a confraternity whose members comforted the condemned on their way to execution. Music and mortality, side by side. Walk down to the broad shopping street of Calle Larga XXII Marzo and follow it east to the extravagant church at its end.

  7. 7. San Moisè & the Teatro San Moisè

    Campo San Moisè, San Marco, 30124 Venezia VE, Italy

    Brace yourself for the façade of San Moisè. Nearly every inch is covered: statues, garlands, obelisks and swirling stone, a riot of white marble that seems about to slide off the front of the church. It was completed in 1668 and paid for by the Fini family, whose busts and coats of arms are more prominent than any saint. John Ruskin loathed it. Plenty of visitors still find it gloriously over the top.

    Opera did not stay inside palaces for long. In 1637 Venice opened the world's first public opera house, at San Cassiano near the Rialto, where anyone with a ticket could get in. Within a few years theatres sprang up all over the city, and one of them stood near this church, towards the Grand Canal: the Teatro San Moisè. In 1640 it staged L'Arianna by Claudio Monteverdi, who was then in charge of the music of San Marco.

    Arianna is famous for a sad paradox: almost all of its music is lost. Only one piece survives complete, the Lament of Ariadne, her cry of despair after Theseus abandons her on an island. It was copied, printed and imitated so widely that it became the model for operatic grief. Imagine a whole opera reduced to one heartbreak... and that heartbreak outliving everything else.

    Jump forward to 3 November 1810. At the Teatro San Moisè an eighteen-year-old Rossini made his professional debut with a one-act comedy, La cambiale di matrimonio, The Marriage Contract. It was a modest piece for a modest house, and it launched the career you heard about at San Beneto. The theatre itself did not survive much longer; it closed in 1818 and was swallowed by later buildings.

    Inside the church lies a man who had nothing to do with music: John Law, the Scottish financier whose paper-money scheme in France collapsed spectacularly in 1720. He died in Venice in 1729, still gambling. Fittingly, the state gambling house, the Ridotto, opened in 1638 just a few steps away. Opera and gambling shared the same customers. Walk north, round the corner behind the Procuratie, to the little basin crowded with gondolas, the Bacino Orseolo.

  8. 8. Bacino Orseolo (Gondoliers' Songs)

    Bacino Orseolo, San Marco, 30124 Venezia VE, Italy

    In this small rectangle of water, hemmed in by buildings, dozens of gondolas bob side by side, black hulls gleaming, their steel prows all pointing the same way. The Bacino Orseolo is a gondola station just behind Piazza San Marco. Gondoliers chat, polish brass sea horses and call out to passers-by. For centuries these men were the city's street musicians.

    Travellers wrote about gondoliers singing verses from Torquato Tasso's epic Jerusalem Delivered, one boat answering another across the water. In October 1786 Goethe arranged to hear it properly: he placed two singers some distance apart along the Giudecca and walked between them as they traded stanzas. He wrote that the effect, heard from afar over the lagoon, moved him deeply, a lament without sorrow.

    Richard Wagner heard something darker. Living in Venice in 1858 while composing the second act of Tristan und Isolde, he lay awake one night and heard a gondolier's long, mournful call echo down a canal. He later wrote that this cry may have suggested the lonely shepherd's tune in the opera's third act. Twenty-five years later, in February 1883, Wagner died in Venice, at Ca' Vendramin Calergi on the Grand Canal.

    The rhythm of rowing even gave music a genre of its own: the barcarolle, a song in a gentle rocking six-eight time. Mendelssohn wrote Venetian gondola songs for piano, Chopin wrote a Barcarolle, and Offenbach composed the most famous of all, the duet Belle nuit, ô nuit d'amour, in The Tales of Hoffmann, in an act set in a Venetian palace. Listen to the hulls knocking softly against each other and you can hear the pulse of it.

    Today you are more likely to hear a hired accordion than Tasso, but the instinct to sing on the water has never quite gone. The next stretch is the longest of the walk. Go through the arcades into Piazza San Marco, cross it and the Piazzetta to the water, then follow the waterfront east over the Ponte della Paglia and along the Riva degli Schiavoni to the white church of the Pietà.

  9. 9. Ospedale della Pietà & Chiesa della Pietà

    Riva degli Schiavoni, Castello, 30122 Venezia VE, Italy

    Facing the lagoon on the Riva degli Schiavoni, the white church of Santa Maria della Visitazione, known to everyone as the Pietà, looks calm and classical. Walk round to its side, into the Calle della Pietà, and look for a stone plaque dated 1548. It calls down God's curses on any parent who abandons a child here while having the means to raise it.

    Because that is what this place was: the Ospedale della Pietà, a home for foundlings. Babies were left at a small opening in the wall, and the institution raised them. The boys learned a trade and left. The girls stayed, and the most talented were trained as musicians, the figlie di coro, the daughters of the choir. Many had no surname, so they were known by their instrument, like the celebrated violinist Anna Maria della Pietà, Anna Maria dal Violin.

    In 1703 a young red-haired priest was hired here as master of the violin: Antonio Vivaldi. On and off for most of the next four decades he taught, rehearsed and composed for these young women, and many of his concertos were written to show off a particular player. Concerts drew diplomats, princes and travellers from all over Europe... though the musicians performed behind iron grilles, heard but barely seen.

    The philosopher Jean-Jacques Rousseau, in Venice in the 1740s, was so enchanted by the singers of the city's ospedali that he begged to meet them. When he finally did, he admitted in his Confessions that several were disappointingly plain... and that their music charmed him all the same. These were stars without faces.

    One more surprise: Vivaldi never set foot in this church. The building you see was designed by Giorgio Massari and begun in 1745, four years after Vivaldi died, poor and far from home, in Vienna. Its oval interior was planned with music in mind, and on the ceiling Giambattista Tiepolo painted the Coronation of the Virgin. The older church stood next door, where a hotel now stands. Cross the next bridge east and turn left up Calle del Dose to Campo Bandiera e Moro.

  10. 10. San Giovanni in Bragora: The Font Where Vivaldi Was Baptised

    Campo Bandiera e Moro, Castello, 30122 Venezia VE, Italy

    Campo Bandiera e Moro is one of those squares that visitors miss by thirty seconds. A brick church with a curved, three-part façade stands on one side, a Gothic palace on another, and children kick a ball against the walls. The church is San Giovanni in Bragora, and this is where Antonio Vivaldi's story begins.

    Vivaldi was born on 4 March 1678, the son of Giovanni Battista, a barber who was also a fine violinist at San Marco. The newborn was so frail that the midwife baptised him at home straight away. Family tradition adds that an earthquake shook Venice that day. Two months later, on 6 May, the full ceremony took place here, at the font you can still see inside.

    His father taught him the violin, and the two sometimes played side by side. The boy's hair gave him his famous nickname once he was ordained in 1703: il Prete Rosso, the Red Priest. He suffered from what he called strettezza di petto, a tightness of the chest, probably asthma, and claimed it stopped him from celebrating Mass. It did not stop him from writing operas, touring and conducting.

    Before you leave, look for the painting above the high altar: the Baptism of Christ by Cima da Conegliano, from the 1490s, with a luminous hilly landscape behind the figures. Vivaldi would have seen it every time he came back to his parish. The square, meanwhile, honours other sons of the city: the brothers Attilio and Emilio Bandiera and Domenico Moro, patriots executed in Calabria in 1844 after a failed uprising.

    The odd name Bragora has puzzled scholars for centuries; nobody is quite sure whether it comes from an old word for a marketplace, for fishing or for something else entirely. Fitting, perhaps, for a composer whose music went missing for two hundred years. Now head north through the quiet backstreets of Castello towards the great Gothic church of Santi Giovanni e Paolo; the last stop is just beyond it, on Barbaria de le Tole.

  11. 11. Ospedaletto & the Sala della Musica

    Barbaria de le Tole, Castello, 30122 Venezia VE, Italy

    Stop in front of the church of the Ospedaletto and try not to laugh: its façade by Baldassare Longhena is crowded with giant heads and straining, muscular figures, like a crowd pressing against a shop window. Behind it lies the Ospedale dei Derelitti, a charitable house for the abandoned, the poor and orphans, and one of the four great ospedali of Venice, alongside the Pietà, the Mendicanti and the Incurabili.

    Each of the four ran its own girls' choir and orchestra, and they competed fiercely. Leading composers, Nicola Porpora and Baldassare Galuppi among them, taught at the ospedali, and visitors went from one to another comparing performances, the way people now compare football teams. Music paid: the concerts drew donations and legacies, and a talented girl could earn a dowry, enough to marry or to enter a convent.

    Hidden inside is one of the loveliest rooms in Venice, the Sala della Musica, decorated in the 1770s. Its walls and ceiling were frescoed by Jacopo Guarana, and on one wall a group of young women perform with their instruments and their music master, as if a concert had been frozen in mid-phrase. It is one of very few images we have of the figlie di coro at work.

    The golden age did not last. When the Republic fell to Napoleon in 1797, the money that had sustained the ospedali dried up, and their musical life faded within a generation. The tradition that had made Venice the place every music lover had to visit simply stopped, and the manuscripts drifted into archives and private collections, where some of them waited two centuries to be played again.

    So that is the score of this walk: a museum of instruments, a conservatory, theatres that burned and rose again, gondoliers, foundling girls and a red-haired priest. A short way north, on the Fondamente Nove, the lagoon opens up, and across the water lies the cemetery island of San Michele, where Igor Stravinsky was buried in 1971, close to Sergei Diaghilev. Even in death, the great names of music chose Venice. Stand still for a moment... the city is still playing.