From the Dome to David: Brunelleschi, Ghiberti and Michelangelo in Florence
A Renaissance art walk through Florence, from the Baptistery's golden doors and Brunelleschi's impossible dome to Fra Angelico's cells at San Marco and Michelangelo's David
Florence · 12 stops · 29 min audio · Generated
-
1. Baptistery of San Giovanni & Ghiberti's Gates of Paradise
Piazza San Giovanni, 50122 Firenze FI, Italy
Stand with your back to the cathedral steps and face the octagon of white and green marble in front of you, striped like a giant medieval jewel box. On the side facing the cathedral, a pair of golden doors glows even on a grey morning, and there is almost always a little crowd pressed against the railings, phones raised.
This is the Baptistery of San Giovanni, dedicated to the patron saint of Florence, and it is older than almost anything around it. It was consecrated in 1059, yet for centuries Florentines insisted it had once been a Roman temple of Mars. Every child of the city was baptised inside, and Dante was one of them. Far from home, writing the Inferno, he still calls it my beautiful San Giovanni.
In 1401 the wealthy cloth merchants' guild announced a competition for a new set of bronze doors. Each finalist had to cast one trial panel showing the sacrifice of Isaac. Two young men stood out: a stubborn goldsmith called Filippo Brunelleschi, and Lorenzo Ghiberti, barely in his twenties. Ghiberti won. Both trial panels survive, side by side, in the Bargello museum, and Florentines still argue about the verdict. Those first doors took Ghiberti over twenty years. Then the guild asked him for another pair... and they took him almost thirty more.
The second pair is the one in front of you: ten gilded panels of Old Testament stories in which streets recede, crowds overlap and hills melt into the distance, as if bronze could have depth. The story goes that Michelangelo called them worthy to be the Gates of Paradise, and the name stuck. Now look closely at the frame. Among the little heads of prophets there is a bald man with a knowing half smile. That is Ghiberti himself, signing his life's work with his own face.
What you are looking at today is a faithful copy. In November 1966 the flooded Arno surged through this square and tore several panels from the doors, and after decades of careful restoration the originals now live indoors, a few minutes from here. As for the loser of 1401, legend says Brunelleschi went off to Rome to measure ancient ruins, and came back with an idea far bigger than a door. Walk along the right-hand side of the cathedral and look up.
-
2. Brunelleschi's Dome & the Cathedral of Santa Maria del Fiore
Piazza del Duomo, 50122 Firenze FI, Italy
Find a spot on the south side of the cathedral, step back as far as the crowds allow, and let your eyes climb. Above the striped marble walls rises an eight-sided drum, and above that the great red dome, ribbed in white, sitting on the city like a hen on her eggs.
When work on this cathedral began in 1296, the plan already called for an enormous octagonal dome. The trouble was that nobody knew how to build one. For decades the church grew around a gaping hole more than forty metres across, open to the sky. The usual method, a wooden frame to hold the vault up while the mortar set, would have swallowed whole forests. In 1418 the city held another competition, and this time Filippo Brunelleschi, the loser of the Baptistery doors, did not lose.
His solution was outrageous: no supporting frame at all. He built two shells, an inner and an outer one, with stairs running between them, and laid the bricks in a herringbone pattern so that each ring locked itself in place as it rose. He invented an ox-driven hoist that could lift loads and lower them again without the oxen ever having to turn round. Millions of bricks went up. The city even made Ghiberti his co-supervisor, and the story goes that Brunelleschi simply took to his bed, pretending to be ill, until everyone saw that work stopped without him.
The dome was consecrated by Pope Eugene the Fourth on the 25th of March 1436, which in those days was New Year's Day in Florence. Brunelleschi died ten years later, just as the lantern on top was started. The gilded ball crowning it was made in Verrocchio's workshop, where a young apprentice called Leonardo da Vinci was learning his trade. Around 1600 lightning knocked the ball down, and a round marble slab in the paving behind the apse is said to mark where it fell.
Now glance at the slender bell tower next to the facade. Giotto designed it and began it in 1334, but he died three years later having built only the lowest level, and others finished it. The marble front of the cathedral, by the way, is not medieval at all; it was completed in 1887. Follow the flank of the church round the apse to the far side of the square, where the workshop that built all this still keeps its treasures.
-
3. Museo dell'Opera del Duomo: Where David Was Carved
Piazza del Duomo 9, 50122 Firenze FI, Italy
On the eastern side of the square, behind the cathedral's apse, a sober facade with a modest doorway hides one of the richest small museums in Europe. It belongs to the Opera del Duomo, the cathedral works, the office that has looked after this building since the 1290s and still does today.
Behind these walls lay the Opera's workshop and yard, and it was here, in 1501, that the cathedral board handed a twenty-six-year-old sculptor a problem nobody wanted. It was a towering block of Carrara marble that had been lying around for decades, already hacked at and abandoned by an earlier sculptor. The workers called it the Giant. It had been meant for a statue high up on one of the cathedral's buttresses. The young man was Michelangelo, and he worked on it here, shut away from prying eyes, for nearly three years. What came out was David.
Inside, the museum keeps the originals of what you saw outside. Ghiberti's restored Gates of Paradise stand behind glass, and a vast hall recreates the cathedral's lost medieval facade, lined with the very statues that once filled its niches. And in a room of her own stands Donatello's Mary Magdalene, carved in wood, gaunt, ragged and toothless, a saint at the end of a life of penance. Florentines who know her rarely forget her.
Then there is the other Michelangelo, the old one. In his seventies he began a Pietà meant for his own tomb, and the hooded figure of Nicodemus holding Christ is traditionally taken as his self-portrait. One day he attacked the group with a hammer. Vasari offers reasons: a flaw in the marble, his own impatience, a servant who kept nagging him to finish. The broken pieces went to that servant, then to a man named Francesco Bandini, and another sculptor patched them up. Christ's left leg is still missing.
So in this one building you have both ends of a life: the young man who turned a reject into a hero, and the old man who could not bear what he had made. Leave the square at its north-eastern corner and walk up the narrow, dead-straight street called Via dei Servi.
-
4. Via dei Servi: The Pilgrims' Road
Via dei Servi 15, 50122 Firenze FI, Italy
Halfway along this narrow street, stop and turn round. Behind you, the dome fills the far end of the street like a painted backdrop on a stage, so close that you can count the white ribs. Ahead, a bronze horseman and the arches of a church portico close the view the other way.
The street takes its name from the Servants of Mary, the Servites, a religious order founded in 1233 by seven Florentine merchants who gave up their businesses to live in prayer. Their church at the far end, the Santissima Annunziata, became the best-loved shrine in the city, and this street became its pilgrim road. For centuries Florentines walked it with candles, prayers and promises.
The busiest day was the 25th of March, the feast of the Annunciation. Until 1750 that was also New Year's Day in Florence, so a document dated February 1500 by a Florentine notary actually belongs, by our reckoning, to 1501. Historians still trip over it. And every 7th of September the street fills again for the Rificolona: children parade with paper lanterns, remembering the country people who once walked into town by night for the fair at the Annunziata, while other children, armed with peashooters, try to set the lanterns on fire.
Just ahead, Via degli Alfani crosses the street. Turn right into it and on the corner of the next block you will pass a strange, many-sided brick building that seems to have stopped halfway. That is the Rotonda of Santa Maria degli Angeli, begun by Brunelleschi in 1434 as one of the first centrally planned churches of the Renaissance. The money, a legacy left for the purpose, was diverted to pay for a war against Lucca, and the walls stayed unfinished for centuries.
It is a very Florentine fate: a genius, a perfect plan, and a city council with other priorities. Keep following Via degli Alfani east to Borgo Pinti, turn right, and look for a gate opening onto a courtyard of slender columns.
-
5. Santa Maria Maddalena de' Pazzi & Perugino's Crucifixion
Borgo Pinti 58, 50121 Firenze FI, Italy
Step through the gate in Borgo Pinti and the street noise falls away. You are in a calm courtyard ringed by slender columns, a private little piazza laid out in front of the church door around 1490 by the architect Giuliano da Sangallo.
The church has changed hands, and names, more than once. In the fifteenth century it belonged to Cistercian monks. In 1628 Carmelite nuns moved in, and the church was later dedicated to their most famous sister, Maria Maddalena de' Pazzi, a mystic who died in 1607 and was made a saint in 1669. Here is the paradox: she came from the same family as the conspirators who in 1478 stabbed Giuliano de' Medici to death during Mass in the cathedral. A century later, the most notorious name in Florence produced its most famous nun.
The treasure is hidden away in the old chapter house, the room where the monks once met. Its end wall is divided by two pillars into three arches, and Pietro Perugino painted a single Crucifixion straight across all three, around 1493 to 1496. The architecture becomes a window frame. Through it you see Christ on the cross, Mary Magdalene kneeling at its foot, the Virgin, Saint John and two saints, and behind them one continuous landscape of soft hills, slim trees and a pale river valley that seems to go on for ever.
Perugino was then the most sought-after painter in Italy, and a boy from Urbino called Raphael would soon learn to paint in exactly this serene, airy manner. Yet Vasari, who loved a bit of gossip, claims the master of all this calm devotion was a man of very little religion, who cared above all about money. Look at those peaceful faces and decide for yourself.
For centuries the fresco lay behind convent walls, seen by very few. Even now this is one of the quietest masterpieces in Florence, often with nobody else in the room. Walk north up Borgo Pinti and turn left into Via della Colonna, which leads you straight into the most harmonious square in the city.
-
6. Ospedale degli Innocenti: Brunelleschi's Foundling Hospital
Piazza della Santissima Annunziata 13, 50121 Firenze FI, Italy
Stand under the long arcade on the east side of the square and look up between the arches. Set into the wall is a row of round blue medallions, and in each one a baby, wrapped tight in white swaddling bands, holds out its arms to you.
This is the Ospedale degli Innocenti, the hospital of the innocents, built for abandoned children and paid for by the silk merchants' guild. In 1419 they asked Brunelleschi to design it, while his dome was still only a plan. He gave them this loggia: slim grey columns, perfect round arches, every proportion worked out from simple ratios, as calm as a sum. Many historians call it the first building of the Renaissance. The hospital opened in 1445, and the very first child left here was a girl named Agata Smeralda.
At the far left end of the arcade you can still see where the wheel was, a revolving window through which a baby could be passed inside without the parent ever being seen. It stayed in use until 1875. Parents often left a token with the child, half a medal, a ribbon, a scrap of cloth, hoping one day to come back with the other half and claim them. Some of those tokens are displayed in the museum inside, and they are hard to look at for long. Florentine surnames like Innocenti, Nocentini and Degli Innocenti go back to the children raised here.
The blue babies were added decades later by Andrea della Robbia, in glazed terracotta, and they became the symbol of the place. Look across the square, too: a century after Brunelleschi, architects built a second arcade on the opposite side as a mirror image of his, turning a whole piazza into one design. The two bronze fountains with their sea monsters are by Pietro Tacca, from 1629.
The institution never stopped working for children, and today it also hosts UNICEF's research office. Now cross the square towards the bronze horseman and the church portico on its northern side.
-
7. Basilica della Santissima Annunziata & the Bronze Grand Duke
Piazza della Santissima Annunziata, 50121 Firenze FI, Italy
Before you step under the portico of the basilica, turn and face the bronze rider in the middle of the square. It is Grand Duke Ferdinando the First, begun by Giambologna and finished after his death by his pupil Pietro Tacca in 1608, and an inscription on the base boasts that the bronze came from cannons captured from the Turks.
An English poet saw something else in him. Florentine legend said the duke had loved a married lady who lived in the palace on the corner of Via dei Servi, and that his statue was turned to gaze at her window for ever. Robert Browning made it a poem, The Statue and the Bust, published in 1855, about two lovers who wait and wait and never dare. Follow the duke's stare and you will find the window.
Now go in. The first space is a small courtyard, the Chiostrino dei Voti, and its walls are a duel between young painters around 1510 to 1517: Andrea del Sarto, and two of his pupils, Pontormo and Rosso Fiorentino. Their twisting figures and acid colours are among the first steps of what we now call Mannerism. Inside the church, by the entrance, a marble shrine designed by Michelozzo protects a fresco of the Annunciation. Legend says that in 1252 the painter fell asleep before finishing the Virgin's face, and woke to find an angel had done it for him. Florentine brides still leave their bouquets here.
Imagine this church crowded with people who never moved. For centuries grateful pilgrims hung life-size wax figures of themselves from the walls and ceiling, dressed in their own clothes, some even on horseback. After he survived the Pazzi conspiracy in 1478, Lorenzo de' Medici had a wax double of himself made, and one was placed here. The whole eerie crowd was cleared away at the end of the eighteenth century.
This is also an artists' church. Giambologna lies in the chapel he designed behind the high altar, Andrea del Sarto and Benvenuto Cellini are buried here too. Leave the square from its top right-hand corner and walk a few blocks north to the gate of the old Medici herb garden.
-
8. Giardino dei Semplici: The Medici Herb Garden
Via Pier Antonio Micheli 3, 50121 Firenze FI, Italy
Through the gate on Via Micheli the traffic fades, and you walk into geometric beds, gravel paths, old greenhouses and trees so tall they shade half the garden. It feels like a secret, and for most visitors to Florence it still is.
This is the Giardino dei Semplici, the garden of simples. In the sixteenth century a simple was a medicinal plant, a single ingredient an apothecary could grind into a remedy. Cosimo the First de' Medici founded the garden in 1545, on land that had belonged to Dominican nuns, only months after the universities of Pisa and Padua had founded theirs. That makes it one of the three oldest botanical gardens in the world.
And it was designed by a sculptor. Niccolò Tribolo was Cosimo's favourite garden maker; he also planned the gardens of the Medici villa at Castello and drew the first design of the Boboli Gardens across the river. For the Medici, a garden was a work of art, a collection and a laboratory all at once, and the line between painter, gardener and scientist was thin.
Cosimo's son Francesco took it even further. In his workshops at the Casino di San Marco, a few streets from here, he experimented with alchemy, rock crystal and furnaces, and around 1575 his craftsmen produced Medici porcelain, the first successful attempt in Europe to imitate Chinese porcelain. Painters like Jacopo Ligozzi made astonishingly precise studies of plants and animals for him. Art and science were the same passion here.
Look for the giant yew near the paths; it is said to have been planted in 1720 by the botanist Pier Antonio Micheli, who gave his name to the street outside. Today the garden belongs to the University of Florence's natural history museum and keeps thousands of plants, from medicinal herbs to tropical rarities in the glasshouses. Leave by the gate, head west to the long, straight Via Cavour, and look for a plain doorway at number 69.
-
9. Chiostro dello Scalzo: Andrea del Sarto in Monochrome
Via Cavour 69, 50129 Firenze FI, Italy
Behind the plain door on Via Cavour lies a small, silent cloister, and every wall around you is painted in one soft earthy tone, as if someone had drawn a whole story in sepia ink directly onto the plaster. There is no gold, no blue, no red. Just light and shadow.
This was the meeting place of a lay brotherhood devoted to Saint John the Baptist, the patron saint of Florence. Everyone called them the Scalzo, the barefoot ones, because the brother who carried their cross in processions walked without shoes. The brotherhood was dissolved in the 1780s, but its cloister survived almost untouched.
The paintings are by Andrea del Sarto, and they took him the best part of fifteen years, from around 1511 into the 1520s. Scene after scene tells the Baptist's life: his birth, his preaching in the desert, the baptism of Christ, Salome dancing, the head on the platter. Why monochrome? Perhaps the brothers had little money, perhaps they wanted austerity; nobody knows for certain. But without colour you see pure drawing, and Andrea's figures have the weight of sculpture.
In 1518 the King of France, Francis the First, invited Andrea to his court, and while he was away his friend Franciabigio painted two of the scenes here. Andrea came home the next year, officially only to fetch his wife Lucrezia. According to Vasari he spent the money the king had given him to buy works of art, and never went back. Look for the difference in hand between the two painters; it is a lovely game.
Vasari called Andrea the painter without errors, a compliment with a sting in it, and Robert Browning, the poet of the bronze duke in the last square, turned that sting into a famous monologue. Few visitors find this place; enjoy having it to yourself. Walk back south along Via Cavour and turn right into Via Ventisette Aprile, where an old convent hides a Last Supper.
-
10. Cenacolo di Sant'Apollonia: Castagno's Last Supper
Via Ventisette Aprile 1, 50129 Firenze FI, Italy
Walk into the long, hushed refectory and the whole far wall becomes a room painted inside the room. Twelve apostles and Christ sit along a white table in a hall of coloured marble, and one dark-bearded man sits alone on your side of it.
This was the dining hall of the Benedictine convent of Sant'Apollonia, whose nuns lived in strict enclosure. Around 1447 they commissioned Andrea del Castagno to paint the Last Supper for them to contemplate during meals. Because outsiders were not allowed in, almost nobody saw it for centuries. Only after the convent was closed in the nineteenth century did the wider world discover what had been hidden here.
Look at the marble panels behind the figures. Each one is wildly veined, and right above Judas and Christ the pattern explodes into something like a storm cloud, as though the stone itself knew what was about to happen. John has fallen asleep on the table. Judas, isolated, already holds the bread. Above the painted room, Castagno frescoed the Resurrection, the Crucifixion and the Deposition, and some of his preparatory drawings, found under the plaster, are displayed nearby.
Castagno has a terrible reputation, and it is mostly undeserved. Vasari wrote that he murdered his fellow painter Domenico Veneziano out of envy. But the archives show that Domenico outlived Castagno by four years. What is true is that in 1440 Castagno painted the effigies of hanged rebels on the wall of the Bargello, as the city did with traitors, and Florentines nicknamed him Andrea of the hanged men.
Leonardo's Last Supper in Milan came half a century later, and it is far more famous. But here you can sit on a bench in near silence and look at Castagno's version for as long as you like. When you are ready, turn left along Via San Gallo, then left again along Via degli Arazzieri, which brings you out in Piazza San Marco.
-
11. Museo di San Marco: Fra Angelico & Savonarola
Piazza San Marco 3, 50121 Firenze FI, Italy
On the north side of the square, beside the plain facade of the church of San Marco, a modest doorway leads into a convent of quiet cloisters. Climb its stairs and, at the top, an angel kneels before the Virgin under a simple portico, painted so softly that people instinctively lower their voices.
In 1436 Cosimo de' Medici, the elder, brought Dominican friars here from Fiesole and paid his architect Michelozzo to rebuild the convent. He even kept a cell of his own for retreats. Michelozzo also built a library, a long airy hall of columns, and Cosimo filled it with manuscripts and let scholars use them. It is often called the first public library of modern Europe.
One of the friars was a painter, Fra Angelico. With his assistants he frescoed the cells upstairs, one scene in each, around forty of them: the Annunciation, the Transfiguration, the mocking of Christ with floating hands slapping a blindfolded face. These were not decorations for visitors. They were meant for one friar alone, to pray in front of, every day, for the rest of his life. Fra Angelico was beatified in 1982, and artists consider him their patron.
Half a century later the convent had a very different prior: Girolamo Savonarola. His sermons against luxury and the Medici held Florence spellbound in the 1490s and led to the burning of vanities in Piazza della Signoria. In April 1498 his enemies besieged the convent, the friars fought back, and the great bell they called La Piagnona rang the alarm. Savonarola was arrested, tortured and executed in May. Even the bell was punished: it was carted through the streets, whipped and sent into exile outside the city. Today it hangs in the museum.
His cell is still upstairs, with his portrait painted by Fra Bartolomeo, one of his followers. And on the corner of this square once lay the sculpture garden of Lorenzo the Magnificent, where a gifted boy called Michelangelo learned to carve. Walk south down Via Ricasoli; where the queue begins, you have arrived at the last stop.
-
12. Galleria dell'Accademia: Michelangelo's David
Via Ricasoli 58/60, 50129 Firenze FI, Italy
The queue along Via Ricasoli tells you what is inside before any sign does. Beyond the door, at the end of a long hall lit from above, a marble giant stands under a dome built just for him, a sling over his shoulder, his weight on one leg, frowning at something only he can see.
When Michelangelo finished David in 1504, nobody wanted to put him on a cathedral buttress any more; he was simply too good. A committee was called to decide where he should stand, and it included Leonardo da Vinci, Botticelli and Perugino. They chose the front of the Palazzo Vecchio, the seat of the republic, so the young hero who beat a giant became a warning to tyrants. Moving him there took four days, and the story goes that Medici supporters threw stones at him along the way.
He is more than five metres tall, and if he looks slightly odd from close up, it is deliberate: the head and hands are oversized, because he was meant to be seen from far below. Notice that he is not celebrating. This is the moment before the fight, the frown, the tense neck, the stone hidden in his right hand. In 1527, during a riot, a bench thrown from a palace window broke his left arm into three pieces, and two teenage apprentices, one of them Giorgio Vasari, gathered the fragments so it could be repaired.
By the nineteenth century rain and frost were eating into the marble, so in 1873 David was moved indoors. The tribune you see was designed for him by Emilio De Fabris, the same architect who gave the cathedral its marble facade. A copy has stood outside the Palazzo Vecchio since 1910. Along the hall, Michelangelo's unfinished Prisoners, carved for the tomb of Pope Julius the Second, seem to be fighting their way out of the stone.
And so this walk comes full circle. You began at a pair of doors that a young Brunelleschi lost, saw the dome he built instead, and stood in the yard where a reject block of marble became this. Florence has always been a city of competitions, second chances and stubborn young men. Take your time with him... he has waited more than five hundred years for you.